#QuestionOfTheDay what's a common plot twist that you could do without?
#fiction #writing #books #anime #manga #videogames #comics #comicbooks #superheroes #TV #television #film #movies #fantasy #scifi #romance #ttrpg #CCGs #boardgames #musicals
Discussion
#QuestionOfTheDay what's a common plot twist that you could do without?
#fiction #writing #books #anime #manga #videogames #comics #comicbooks #superheroes #TV #television #film #movies #fantasy #scifi #romance #ttrpg #CCGs #boardgames #musicals
@ami_angelwings Maybe a strange one, but I hate when the "twist" is that the whole thing was a right-wing moral play all along. Bonus points if making the moral play work requires throwing out the entire premise in the third act.
See Ghostbusters (government regulation is bad), Bee Movie (labor unions make everyone lazy and destroy the economy), or even Ayn Rand's Anthem (women should be subservient). At least with Rand's later work, she feels less obliged to tricking her audience...
@ami_angelwings I'll third "it was all a dream", but specifically to contrast it with "time travel made it so none of that happened", which I have grown much more tolerant of over the years. At least in a time travel story, you're seeing how the actual characters would react in a situation.
@ertchin @ami_angelwings The "time travelers go back to prevent a historical catastrophe, but their actions in the past are the trigger without which the catastrophe would never have happened" trope is also interesting. A good example is Jack Finney's From Time to Time. A think tank finds scattered artifacts of a gleaming alternate reality of continuous progress that would have existed if WWI hadn't occurred. They determine that the sinking of the Titanic doomed a diplomatic mission that would have prevented the war. So they sent someone back to prevent the iceberg collision, and they grab the wheel and randomly alter the ship's course by just a bit. Turns out it's the new course that results in the collision.
@KevinCarson1 There's a work I won't name because I would be spoiling it tremendously, but part of its conceit is that the protagonist is repeatedly shown they cannot change a particular moment in their observed past because it led directly to their current existence as it is ... so they come up with a way to make the observed past lead to a better outcome.