@stefan @tchambers
But we already have visibility controls (which I didn't believe bsky has) adding reply controls makes the possibility matrix quite complex. Maybe if we simplified it so you only had reply controls on public posts?
I think reply controls being only available for public posts should be fine. But those are two different things, and I like how you can mix and match them for the right experience.
Maybe you want to be private, carefully vet your followers, and only share with them. Maybe you like engaging with strangers, so you post everything publicly and openly.
Maybe you want to share something publicly to get your ideas out there, but only care to hear from your curated network. A bit like posting on a blog with comments disabled. Or only allowing comments from people registered on your site. Everyone gets to read, but you don't care to moderate or respond to replies.