Mastodon is asking for UX and accessibility feedback on its app while the new UI is still in flux. That is the cheap moment to be heard. Specific reports with the screen, the assistive tech, and what broke are far more useful than "this is confusing."
@zl2tod @shlee @uxbrad yeah, the followers only loophole leads to harrasment-by nazi's, bots and harrassers. Being able to post a followers only comment on public posts should Not be allowed, nor should being able to DM strangers as a default setting. We want better controls over who can tag us in private or followers only replies on public posts.
@MamaLake@beige.party @zl2tod@mastodon.online @shlee@aus.social @uxbrad@mastodon.social
Sorry, but both of these have extremely legitimate use-cases, I for example reply on a relatively regular basis to public posts with my followers-only alt-account, where I post almost exclusively followers-only, but quite a few people, including mutuals (in very real cases: mutuals on main, not on alt, because I am very picky with who gets to follow there!), are making public posts on similar topics and I do at times like to interact with those in a way that those people and my followers can see, but that I don’t want to expose to everyone.
And even if you removed it, I genuinely don’t see what would stop anyone from just making a post that links to the post they want to harass, which is definitely no longer preventable, since servers that allow this shit are going to be run by biggots anyways, so it’s not even clear what benefit this would bring.
Similarly I have repeatedly gotten DMs from strangers, for example in response to public posts, see e.g. this poll, which provided valuable information that the people in question were not willing to share publicly.
Another example are DMs where people ask about whether it is fine to follow, which also only works if DMs are open by default.
I can see a point for allowing users to restrict DMs to established contacts, but it should really not be the default
@MamaLake@beige.party @shlee@aus.social @zl2tod@mastodon.online @uxbrad@mastodon.social
I am a marginalized person, there has literally been a relatively large harassment campaign here where I was clearly one of the main targets, so I would appreciate if we could leave out the implication that this is not about me and that I value my own comfort unreasonably high.
But even to that point of safety: A bigger problem is when I have to choose between posting material that I would actually really prefer to not be publicly available (which I seem to have been pretty successful at, seeing that the harasser was only able to bring up stuff that was intentionally public) either publicly or not at all, because at that point we are back to telling people that they basically have to leave the platform.
Now, as I said, I don’t see an issue with being able to turn of DMs for non-followers/followees, but I really am not convinced of the usefulness of blocking responses with reduced visibility and it should at the utmost be opt-in, not opt-out.
Because yes, this feature may have been misused, but just because something is used in bad ways, doesn’t mean that the cost of having it doesn’t outweigh the benefits, which is an especially important consideration if there are very obvious alternatives (such as linking to posts instead of responding to them), because you risk creating something that will exclusively inconvenience the people that are not a problem.
@Fiona @MamaLake @zl2tod @uxbrad I think this falls into the “using technology to solve social problems” line. The problem of “everything can be abused” means some people think the answer is locking down.
But I think we just need the ability to “break in case of emergency” button that gives moderators access to additional metadata or data.
I don’t think there is an answer… even if you made mastodon perfect, they will move to discord to coordinate. Cannot fix that.
@uxbrad fix the loophole that allows for harassment via followers only dog piling