@dansup I like the second one from the second row.

@dansup

@dansup I like the pixel one because it matches the name and the product.
Less keen on rainbow iris(es) that are to close tot the beach ball of death on macOS.

@dansup right on the first row or third

@dansup
The current one is good actually.

@dansup I know it will be the leftmost one in the 2nd row 😉

What makes it stand out to me are its unique, but still simple shape and its nice retro colours.

A regular circle is a bit boring, and the rightmost leaf shape looks a bit too ”aggressive” with its sharp corners.

The monochromatic icons could also be slightly more interesting, and I fear they might not provide sufficient internal contrast to be recognisable easily at small scales.

I feel like the colours of the rightmost icon in the last row is a bit generic and that they are frequently used by those rather cheap photo-editing apps/websites.

@dansup
All the three last ones on the third row are nice.

@dansup
1,1 1,2 3,2 6,3 4,4 are great

@dansup number 14 is the strongest IMO

@dansup
Simple is good so it doesn't get unrecognizable when scaled down in small UI, also needs to look fine on dark/light modes (or have two versions)

Although the current logo is busy, it does stand out when you put it next to other platforms

@dansup The last one on the third row feels great

@dansup

If you're asking for opinions... Disclaimer, I might not even use Pixelfed (but maybe this is somehow useful still).

1st row: none

2nd row: nice, but none

3rd row: good, I vote for all but especially 5 and 6 (last two from left-to-right)

4th row: none

@dansup
It was easier to explain like this:

@dansup

I'm personally choosing the 3rd row 4th column so when Dan releases some merch I can buy me some stickers 😁

PS row 2 column 1 and row 2 column 2 somehow remind me of NBC/Peacock and the old Mac spinning wheel respectively. 😄 The former also reminds me of one of the candidates for PF back when 🤷

@dansup my graphic designer girlfriend and I both like third row rightmost the best, and the third row in general significantly more than the other rows.

@dansup 5 colours in a pinwheel has some similarities to the Immich logo.

That said, I'm not suggesting that you avoid that. I like rainbow colours to indicate photos and the camera iris effect enhances that association.

Just think about how they relate or do not relate.

@dansup the pixelated one (at the end of the third row) makes the most sense for sure 💯

@dansup

I like the 2nd from the right on the third row.

@dansup Somehow top right or bottom right ones stand out to me.