Discussion
Loading...

Post

Log in
  • About
  • Code of conduct
  • Privacy
  • Users
  • Instances
  • About Bonfire
Federation Bot
Federation Bot
@Federation_Bot  ·  activity timestamp 4 months ago

So apparently a lot of people are mad enough at some Windows thing to be contemplating Linux (again), and there is (justifiable) concern that this will mostly end in tears, because people who are forced to use something are likely to resent and hate every moment of it.

I'm in the frustrating position of a long-time Linux enjoyer who is a computer toucher *but also* really mad about the widespread acceptance of the idea that you have to have some kind of special aptitude to use a computer as something other than an appliance, because technology is scary and complicated (and that therefore there's no hope of mere mortals coping with the rough-around-the-edges here-be-dragons environment of even the most user-friendly distro).

I think this is a harmful idea, originally popularised by people who profit from selling appliances, regularly disproved by ordinary people who teach themselves how to get the computer to do cool stuff because nobody told them that they can't because it's too hard. And as much as I don't want to discourage anyone from learning stuff on whatever OS they have right now, this is not an OS-agnostic issue.

It genuinely makes a difference whether your environment is a proprietary black box that allows you limited access to its workings, or something that you can take apart and look at and modify. You may not *understand* all of what you're looking at, but you can ask someone who does! And maybe that someone is an asshole who won't help you, or maybe it's three people who are going to argue about it. The point is that it's *possible*. This is *knowable information*.

However... I realise that a lot of the people who are currently fed up with Windows 100% believe that they are just "not technical", and I think that the worst possible time to try to encourage anyone to step out of their comfort zone and learn something new is when they have to, because the thing they actually want to use is broken. They don't want platitudes; they just want a computer that fucking works, just like their old computer.

  • Copy link
  • Flag this post
  • Block
Adrianna Pińska
Adrianna Pińska
@confluency@hachyderm.io replied  ·  activity timestamp 4 months ago

I don't know if this problem has a good solution: we could say that FOSS projects "should" make an effort to be more beginner-friendly, and to make more polished and bulletproof GUIs, but ultimately this is the same kind of wishful thinking as saying that users "should" make more of an effort to be proactive about learning. Both of these groups of people are collections of individuals making decisions based on their own needs: FOSS devs are making the software that they want to use, and novice users just want something that works *now* the way they expect it to, and they both resent being told that they "should" do things differently.

I guess my advice to anyone eyeing Linux speculatively right now is: if you can, try it out before it's an emergency. If you have one spare old laptop, install one of the boring reliable options (I hate the Best Distro For New People discourse, but probably pick Lubuntu, Xubuntu or Mint) and play around with it and see how much of your normal computer activities you can do on it.

I know this is leaving out kilometres of caveats. I don't want to lie to you: it could go very smoothly or you could hit some weird speed bumps. It will require some investment of time and effort. It's not a drop-in replacement even under optimal conditions. I really don't want you to attempt this while you're angry and annoyed. But if you can make the time, your investment is likely to be rewarded.

What's really great, if you can get it, is hands-on help. In the olden times, we had these local meetups called Linux User Groups, where Linux users at various levels of expertise could meet in person and help each other, and share copies of installation media (back when we accessed the internet through a straw attached to a potato). They've kind of died out, at least in my country, because everyone is online. Fellow computer touchers, maybe we should bring them back.

  • Copy link
  • Flag this comment
  • Block

bonfire.cafe

A space for Bonfire maintainers and contributors to communicate

bonfire.cafe: About · Code of conduct · Privacy · Users · Instances
Bonfire social · 1.0.2-alpha.7 no JS en
Automatic federation enabled
Log in
  • Explore
  • About
  • Members
  • Code of Conduct