The pointless loop of students using AI to write papers that professors use AI to grade is the ultimate endpoint of treating education as a product rather than a process.
@benlockwood they're trying to break graduate student unions
@benlockwood A college degree is only to get a job in the US, this is just speeding up the process.
It's not like you get to study anything worthwhile unless you have money or you get lucky and the degree you get isn't rendered obsolete by tech or socially deemed useless by not being a STEM degree. If you take out student loans on top of that, you're in debt and jobless.
Might as well just pay someone to hand you a degree at this point so you can start working as a debt slave sooner, or the entire educational system needs to be reworked. There's no middle ground anymore with AI tools in the picture.
@benlockwood A college degree is only to get a job in the US, this is just speeding up the process.
It's not like you get to study anything worthwhile unless you have money or you get lucky and the degree you get isn't rendered obsolete by tech or socially deemed useless by not being a STEM degree. If you take out student loans on top of that, you're in debt and jobless.
Might as well just pay someone to hand you a degree at this point so you can start working as a debt slave sooner, or the entire educational system needs to be reworked. There's no middle ground anymore with AI tools in the picture.
@benlockwood It tends to be the same everywhere. The inherent nature of people wanting to be lazy and seeking shortcuts is winning over the necessary process to be able to learn. Sad.
@benlockwood
maybe the students should pay for their virtual degree with virtual money
@benlockwood The goal seems to be to fire the profs, collect the tuition and have all the students stay home. ,
@benlockwood It's worth pointing out that it's the Haas School of Business, which was newly constructed and lavishly funded while liberal arts and social sciences were being defunded at UC Berkeley.
@benlockwood I'm guessing this tool was mostly written by unpaid graduate students, who were previously not paid for the time they spent grading exams.
@benlockwood Why not just streamline AI "education" to its natural end point where you tell an AI bot which degree you're want, it spits out a diploma with your name so you get placed in a button pushing factory for that degree field. Why even pretend you're teaching or learning anything in between, since none of that matters, only the paper matters and there's no longer any work associated with being granted a degree.
@benlockwood We just need to replace students and teachers with AI agents and we'll all done then
What was the purpose of education anyway?
@benlockwood I'm coaching a student at the moment who has agreed not to use AI for any of their big assignments. They told me that their teacher straight up told them she 'uses AI to grade them'.
I am genuinely horrified. It would never even have occurred to me to do that!
Grading is how you learn about the student's abilities and gaps - impossible if you're not actually doing the grading yourself.
@benlockwood I present to you: Stanislaw Lem, The Washing Machine Tragedy, see, e.g., https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1981/11/30/the-washing-machine-tragedy (thanks to @AndreasZeller for identifying the story from a summary and for the link)
The Washing-Machine Tragedy