What do you do if you're reviewing a paper and the journal policy clearly states all code and data must be supplied, but the authors only share the source code--no input data, no configs, no run scripts, no plotting scripts?
Discussion
Loading...
@petebachant you can write to the editor that you can't proceed with the review. Manuscripts analyzing register data can claim an exception https://renebekkers.wordpress.com/2025/01/21/raising-the-bar-for-peer-review-invitations/
