Leninists! Do me a favor and apprise me of your commitments up-front, so I can block you from the get-go and save us both some time?
@iamdavidobrien Whiiiiiiich is why I said “Leninist,” not “Marxist”?
Just context, Adam.
@iamdavidobrien To answer your question: I think one can – in fact, must – distinguish Marx the epochally-insightful economic and social theorist from Marx the political thinker.
The contributions of the former remain vital in any serious attempt to reckon with the facts of our existence. The latter, though? The verdict of history is in, and it’s not looking so good for him.
So yes, I am aware of something “better.” I talk about it all the time, too.
Remember: a Leninist is someone who doesn’t despise absolute power – they just think the wrong people hold it.
@adamgreenfield cops are good if we are the cops
@lzg nobody likes a chekist.
@adamgreenfield guilty as charged! i appreciate you asking politely for my commitments up-front, and here they are. i am committed to:
1. the overthrowal of the rule of capital and destruction of its entire bourgeois social structure by the communist revolution of the proletariat,
2. which in the intermediate period between capitalist rule and the development into communism, takes the form of the dictatorship of the proletariat,
3. and which is led by the communist party, the unitary and central organ of proletarian revolution founded on the program of communism.
as a materialist i do not believe in any "absolute powers". there are of course "absolute dictators" and "absolute monarchs" but these are mythical self-aggrandizing titles which hide the reality of the capitalist state's function from people.
as for the dictatorship of the proletariat, it is an armed central body aiming to take over the whole world and suppress the counterrevolutionary forces that oppose it. that is why we call it a dictatorship. to call it an "absolute power" is more or less trying to say the same thing, but clearly we marxists or leninists speak a different language than you do.
i hope i have contributed positively in any way at all. have a good one!
@redrozalia Christ, can you even hear yourself?
@adamgreenfield
hey man, you asked, i answered honestly. you were looking for confirmation that you didnt like leninism and i happily gave you exactly that. i know what i sound like :)
@redrozalia Look, I get that the number of people who have ever been convinced to change their mind as the result of an argument on the internet stands at zero, so I’m not going to waste time trying to convince you of the weakness of that position.
What I cannot for the life of me is *why* anyone with two brain cells to knock together would espouse such a position in current year. Assuming, arguendo, that you’re *not* actually motivated by a desire to compensate for personal powerlessness, what’s the appeal of making assertions that have been falsified over and over again?
What pleasure is there in expressing yourself via a concatenation of thought-terminating clichés that can’t survive a moment’s inspection? What work does it do for you to apprehend the twenty-first century via categories that were arguably outmoded by the midpoint of the twentieth? Please, help me understand. Because so far as I can see, that rhetoric is maximum cringe & that politics deader still than cyberpunk.
@redrozalia And finally, I’ve been around the block enough times to understand that the militant-Leninist-at-20-to-midtier-Realtor-at-40 pipeline is a real thing. So you’ll forgive me if I don’t take your rhetoric at face value.
@adamgreenfield
this is a pretty long-winded way of asking me with respect to my political positions, "why?"
i have been reading the works of marx, engels, lenin, and others like them for about seven or eight years by now. i am reasonably familiar with the history of communism, its successes, its failures. and in spite of those failures, i think communist theory is truthful and useful. but i could easily be wrong, ive been wrong about many things before. (if i become a realtor at 40, i will let you know! should be satisfying for you.)
but so far i dont really see you telling me how or why i am wrong. you said a lot of words, some of them directly contemptuous of lenin, but made no serious attempt to critique him or his stances. mostly you are just acting incredulous that a leninist has the nerve to exist in the big '26.
sorry to disappoint you!
@redrozalia Yes: as I said, if you really think the world as it exists now can adequately be accounted for by theory capped decades before the atomic bomb, the discovery of DNA, the advent of the birth-control pill or the first Ethernet connection, I’m not even going to try to argue you out of those beliefs. It’s futile. And in any event, experience will do a much better job of it than I’d ever be able to.
@adamgreenfield
quantum mechanics comes from the same time period as leninism and precedes all of those things too. of course, further discoveries in physics have been made since, but quantum mechanics didnt stop being true when that happened. so you see why i dont take this as a knockout blow. you are much more interested in making arguments for why you shouldnt have to argue against leninism rather than arguments against leninism—but why cant you come up with better ones?
as for reading your books, i might. but you could just level with me and admit to being a social democrat or anarchist or whatever, you dont have to be scared.
@redrozalia Because I’m no kind of -ist, and affirm no -ism – indeed, I think ists and isms are a not-inconsiderable part of the challenge we face.
But sure, if it makes you more comfortable, I’ll answer to “anarchist.” I thought that was obvious.
@adamgreenfield
yeah, sounds like something an anarchist would say about -ists and -isms.
@redrozalia And maybe there’s a reason for that? Maybe it’s foolish to expect a static doctrine to guide you in a dynamic set of conditions?
tl;dr That’s not the burn you think it is.
@adamgreenfield
anarchism is old. the criticisms you have of me, the criticisms goldman had of the bolsheviki, and the criticisms that bakunin had of marx all sound identical. what are you calling a static doctrine? who are you calling out of date, old-fashioned, outmoded? one difference between me and you is that i proudly call myself a marxist, a leninist, and a communist, and you timidly shrink away from admitting to your anarchism.
Pol philosophy
@redrozalia
Why should anyone support a political project that'll turn around and mass murder, exile, and imprison everyone. The carnivalesque terror of the snake eating its own tail under Stalinism, among the other failures in history is sign enough of where authoritarian Marxism leads. The International split was vindicated a long time ago.
A successful liberatory movement is diverse and practical with experimentation which shows what's effective, as explained under the economic anarchy option. People follow action rather than by ideology being imposed.
re: Pol philosophy
@HeliosPi
firstly, i gotta hand this to you: you actually have something substantial to say to me, unlike adam over here making dismissive comments about my age and profile picture. thank you, i appreciate this a lot!
for the sake of illustrating your point, could you give me a historical example of a successful and diverse liberatory movement? because as someone very interested in history, my problem with anarchism is that it does not accurately analyze how a revolution happens or why it succeeds.
the diversity of a revolutionary movement is a feature of its youth, i.e. it is a movement whose internal divisions have not yet come to a head. the young first international was diverse, its internal divisions developed but did not split it, but the defeat of the paris commune made its splitting inevitable.
on the other hand, the russian revolution succeeded and persisted as revolutionary (at least prior to the stalinist period) for longer than the paris commune, in part because the bolsheviki took the infamous but necessary step of repressing movements that threatened it, including left-populists, left-democrats, and anarchists.
brutal class war, repression, dictatorship, execution. these things are pretty bad, right? unfortunately they are also persistent features of present bourgeois society. if there were a way to overthrow bourgeois society without the use of brutal class war, repression, dictatorship, execution, as made use of by the bolsheviki, then i would prefer that presumably nicer and better way. but i am unconvinced that it exists.
@redrozalia
it seems a little disingenuous to claim the russian revolution as "successful" on the basis that they did in fact overthrow the government and some number of organizations claiming to be them that at worst descended from them continued to exist up until some point in time (the 90s? the present?). I feel that a "successful" revolution somewhat necessitates actually accomplishing the goals set out beforehand. Are the Russian people more liberated today than other nations that overthrew monarchies?
We could of course go on, but to what end? This conversation has been ongoing for longer than any of us have been alive. Which is to say that I do agree that Adam was not arguing in good faith, jumping from an antagonistic statement into ad hominems, but that he also clearly didn't intend to argue in good faith (hence the opening antagonism) and merely sort of let himself be sealioned into continuing to talk.
@redrozalia
To argue this sort of thing in good faith is to begin an endless conversation with an internet stranger who has a decade less experience than you and considerably more time for pointlessly arguing on the internet with strangers.
Go forth and argue with actual people in real life. Perhaps you will find your comrades to crush us all beneath your heels. Watch out for cults.
re: Pol philosophy
@vlt
@redrozalia
Yar, there's no obligation to argue in good faith. I too share the dirision, how can there still be people who subscribe to this ideology after more than a century of authoritarian cimmunisms' failures and counterrevolutionary modus operandi? Maybe it is best to ridicule and isolate adherents to such a ideology for historicaly ruining movements for freedom...
A few clarifying responses then some further thoughts for food. The black army was based in Ukraine and initially fought with the red army against the white army until being betrayed. The Russian revolution happened because of the general populace, not because of the Bolsheviks, who were more like opportunists. Anarchists in Russia weren't well-established at that time yet, although elsewhere anarchists provided a lot of material and prisoner support to people there.
I appreciate Rozalia's honesty that ideological authoritarian communists would do revolutionary terror again. I wonder why this ideological current hasn't changed since then, like the autonomists.
Bolsheviks not only targeted their political rivals and enemies, their authoritarian terror expanded to the general populace. Ministers had quotas of subservients to target, so they made up targets even tho there was no evidence or reason. So the general populace protested this police state and then the ministers were killed or imprisoned too. Seen by the repeated purges of the ranks of the nomenklatura during the Stalin regime. Hence this description of carnivalesque terror, going round and round. The regional leaders used these purges to consolidate their machines and get rid of inconvenient people, but then they too were purged a few years later.
98 out of 139 members of the central committee were killed. Of Ukraine central committee only three out of 200 hundred survived. Of 1,996 party leaderd at the seventeenth congress in 1934, 1,108 were imprisoned or murdered. In the provinces 319 out of 385 secretaries & 2,210 out of 2,750 district secretaries died. (Pg. 249, In Defense of Lost Causes by Zizek)
This is much like the Jacobin terror of the Paris Commune, where legit revolutionaries were killed along with everyone else as the process got out of control, following its logical direction.
re: Pol philosophy
Further, anarchist theory explores social movements, uprisings, and the such a lot a lot. A good recent essay looks at the Gen Z revolts in SE Asia. "The Black Scare and the Party of Anarchy
Notes from the Philippines on the Second Battle of Mendiola" https://crimethinc.com/2026/06/30/the-black-scare-and-the-party-of-anarchy-notes-from-the-philippines-on-the-second-battle-of-mendiola
The party of anarchy is a juxtaposition with the party of order and the caucus of false critics.
"The party of anarchy is not a particular organizational formation, but a spontaneous emergence that cohered at a time of high morale among our class. As in Indonesia and Nepal, it emerged outside the milieu known as the “left.” "
They explore the failures of the caucus of false critics who best interest is to maintain legitimacy to reform the current system and be set to assume the role of the party of order if the current order were to collapse.
I recommend this essay for more they explore, such as the limits of the revolts and what support people can do now and in the future.
Also also Party formations on the left impede revolutionary struggle. The Black Scare covers this. I want to highlight analysis from the global uprisings of 1968, with part 2 of an essay about the decade long '68 in Japan. "Fragmentation, Centralization, and Civil War in the Japanese Ultra-Left
By Harumasa Abe" https://illwill.com/uchigeba
The revolt there was undercut by violenct rivalries between different leftist political formations, with authoritarian communist bents. After that debacle the only ideological formations continuing were decentralized community activist groups.
@HeliosPi Forget it, Jake – it’s Chinatown.
@vlt Not so much that, as that I don’t believe reasoned arguments will dissuade someone who hasn’t arrived at and does not maintain their position by reasoning.
Everything about this person’s demeanor and self-presentation suggests that they derive a meaningful chunk of their sense of identity from their adherence to a label and a cluster of associated symbols. If everything we already know about Leninism and its fruits doesn’t immediately and facially disqualify it for them, nothing some random dude on the internet says will change that. You engage with people like that only if, and as long as, it amuses you to do so.
Sometimes you just gotta son a herb.
(Which is to say: you have no obligation to “debate in good faith” with anybody who affirms the atrocious. Some ideologies are facially absurd, and you needn’t engage seriously with anyone currently saddled with them, however much they might squeal COME BACK AND DEBATE ME BRO.)
I'm more a Marxist, in the sense that, as far as I can see, his critique of Capital has been pretty much spot-on.
I mean, I'm not seeing anything better out there. Are you?
@adamgreenfield