Leninists! Do me a favor and apprise me of your commitments up-front, so I can block you from the get-go and save us both some time?
@iamdavidobrien Whiiiiiiich is why I said “Leninist,” not “Marxist”?
Just context, Adam.
@iamdavidobrien To answer your question: I think one can – in fact, must – distinguish Marx the epochally-insightful economic and social theorist from Marx the political thinker.
The contributions of the former remain vital in any serious attempt to reckon with the facts of our existence. The latter, though? The verdict of history is in, and it’s not looking so good for him.
So yes, I am aware of something “better.” I talk about it all the time, too.
Remember: a Leninist is someone who doesn’t despise absolute power – they just think the wrong people hold it.
@adamgreenfield cops are good if we are the cops
@lzg nobody likes a chekist.
@adamgreenfield guilty as charged! i appreciate you asking politely for my commitments up-front, and here they are. i am committed to:
1. the overthrowal of the rule of capital and destruction of its entire bourgeois social structure by the communist revolution of the proletariat,
2. which in the intermediate period between capitalist rule and the development into communism, takes the form of the dictatorship of the proletariat,
3. and which is led by the communist party, the unitary and central organ of proletarian revolution founded on the program of communism.
as a materialist i do not believe in any "absolute powers". there are of course "absolute dictators" and "absolute monarchs" but these are mythical self-aggrandizing titles which hide the reality of the capitalist state's function from people.
as for the dictatorship of the proletariat, it is an armed central body aiming to take over the whole world and suppress the counterrevolutionary forces that oppose it. that is why we call it a dictatorship. to call it an "absolute power" is more or less trying to say the same thing, but clearly we marxists or leninists speak a different language than you do.
i hope i have contributed positively in any way at all. have a good one!
@redrozalia Christ, can you even hear yourself?
@adamgreenfield
hey man, you asked, i answered honestly. you were looking for confirmation that you didnt like leninism and i happily gave you exactly that. i know what i sound like :)
@redrozalia Look, I get that the number of people who have ever been convinced to change their mind as the result of an argument on the internet stands at zero, so I’m not going to waste time trying to convince you of the weakness of that position.
What I cannot for the life of me is *why* anyone with two brain cells to knock together would espouse such a position in current year. Assuming, arguendo, that you’re *not* actually motivated by a desire to compensate for personal powerlessness, what’s the appeal of making assertions that have been falsified over and over again?
What pleasure is there in expressing yourself via a concatenation of thought-terminating clichés that can’t survive a moment’s inspection? What work does it do for you to apprehend the twenty-first century via categories that were arguably outmoded by the midpoint of the twentieth? Please, help me understand. Because so far as I can see, that rhetoric is maximum cringe & that politics deader still than cyberpunk.
@redrozalia And finally, I’ve been around the block enough times to understand that the militant-Leninist-at-20-to-midtier-Realtor-at-40 pipeline is a real thing. So you’ll forgive me if I don’t take your rhetoric at face value.
@adamgreenfield
this is a pretty long-winded way of asking me with respect to my political positions, "why?"
i have been reading the works of marx, engels, lenin, and others like them for about seven or eight years by now. i am reasonably familiar with the history of communism, its successes, its failures. and in spite of those failures, i think communist theory is truthful and useful. but i could easily be wrong, ive been wrong about many things before. (if i become a realtor at 40, i will let you know! should be satisfying for you.)
but so far i dont really see you telling me how or why i am wrong. you said a lot of words, some of them directly contemptuous of lenin, but made no serious attempt to critique him or his stances. mostly you are just acting incredulous that a leninist has the nerve to exist in the big '26.
sorry to disappoint you!
Sometimes you just gotta son a herb.
(Which is to say: you have no obligation to “debate in good faith” with anybody who affirms the atrocious. Some ideologies are facially absurd, and you needn’t engage seriously with anyone currently saddled with them, however much they might squeal COME BACK AND DEBATE ME BRO.)
I'm more a Marxist, in the sense that, as far as I can see, his critique of Capital has been pretty much spot-on.
I mean, I'm not seeing anything better out there. Are you?
@adamgreenfield