"We are talking about productivity gains at several orders of magnitude. Projects that might take a year now take months, and months become weeks."
this is from an AI slop (checks notes) *reduction* policy, you say? fascinating
"We are talking about productivity gains at several orders of magnitude. Projects that might take a year now take months, and months become weeks."
this is from an AI slop (checks notes) *reduction* policy, you say? fascinating
@giflian libreboot, which is claiming this is slop reduction and not the wholehearted endorsement the actual words read as
https://libreboot.org/news/clankers.html
archive: https://archive.ph/NF0t1#selection-307.819-307.964
it's even on a page called "clankers.html"
I cannot rightly apprehend etc
@davidgerard @giflian It's a reasonable take for a project that has a SINGLE maintainer. Attacking maintainers that have been providing free software and hardware to the community for decades simple for recognizing reality does the anti-AI movement and the free software movement a disservice.
@thestrangelet @giflian saying that the slop bot is a fabulous productivity booster is in no way a slop reduciton policy, what sort of bizarre nonsense is this. words fucking mean things.
@davidgerard it’s interesting to read this stuff in the midst of what’s happening with Wall Street. Is now the time to give up on banning AI code outright (or as best one can, given dependencies)? We all know that tokens are still being subsidized, too…
@giflian in no way whatsoever, no. it wont fall over tomorrow, but gravity is working right now.
The quote continue with
"This is true specifically of reverse engineering. It has been my experience that AI otherwise tends to slow the user down"
And then a little farthest
"On AI-based reverse engineering though:
The problem again though is that this still requires human knowledge, and thus such benefits are indeed superficial"
And the conclusion is
"Really though, I just hope we one day return to a world where human beings think for themselves. It remains to be seen what the full long-term consequences of AI are, but I basically think nothing good will ever come of it. Any short term benefits we might perceive now will mean nothing in thirty years. I’m not optimistic at all.
I basically think we’re completely screwed.
"
After reading most of the page, I tend to understand his position, which is well argumented and could not be resumed with a little quote taken out of context.
@davidgerard my drug reduction policy where I go from no drugs to only a bit of heroin
@davidgerard This is the weirdest part of the AI mania. If there are *already* "orders of magnitude improvement in productivity", why am I not hearing *users* of software excited about how in the past year they've seen improvements that would previously take 30 years? And excitement about a video game made with a team of 3 that would previously take 100 people?
And if none of that is happening... what the fuck actually is it that's improved in productivity by orders of magnitude?
(I don't doubt some people are "writing" orders of magnitude more lines of code, but that isn't exactly a good thing.)
@ids1024 yes, it's fully embracing the propaganda. describing the policy as fully embracing the propaganda is an objectively true statement.
@davidgerard
Calling it propaganda seems like an understatement. If the AI labs were saying "coding agents increase developer productivity by 30%", maybe it's true (it's hard to measure), but you shouldn't repeat their marketing uncritically without good independent evidence.
But this is full delusion. "Orders of magnitude" improvement at certain very specific tasks? Sure, maybe. But as a general statement... if this were true it would be evident to everyone with an internet connection even if they don't know what a programming language is.
But if you just go touch grass and then ask random people on the street, will they say this is a particularly exciting time for improvement in software?
It is about very specific tasks though. The next line is:
> This is true specifically of reverse engineering. It has been my experience that AI otherwise tends to slow the user down,
@ids1024 @davidgerard THIS - if orders of magnitude in productivity is being achieved we should see it! Point to the deliverables! It's all very much "pics or it didn't happen" territory and nobody is actually showing the pics
I believe more code is being generated than ever before. And as someone who has worked on software projects that's actually a problem more often than an indication of solutions...
@davidgerard I gotta go read the whole thing. It's long. I only got to the bit where Leah was talking about removing slopped paches from upstream.
@lykso that's a banger of a fucking line though. what a line to include and claim to be against AI slop.
@davidgerard if it goes from a year to a month that's only one order of magnitude (30 days to 365 days)
There's no way we could fail to notice "several orders of magnitude"
@davidgerard where is this from?