RE: https://mas.to/@carnage4life/117661282479818351
Can just regular off-the-shelf GPU chips even WORK in space? There are so many problems with this plan it's stunning.
RE: https://mas.to/@carnage4life/117661282479818351
Can just regular off-the-shelf GPU chips even WORK in space? There are so many problems with this plan it's stunning.
@sundogplanets the.... financial gravity of their situation...
Is more amusing than anything.bon multiple levels.
Banks ain't gonna fo that.
@sundogplanets not for long I bet…
@sundogplanets
Maybe with shielding.
No-one has yet explained to me how they get rid of the heat.
@sundogplanets I mean... they probably can, if you manage to cool them somehow, and shield them from the radiation? But I'd think the more sensible solution would be to design chips from the ground up to be usable in space, rather than trying to make regular designed-for-earth-conditions gpus work in space...
@sundogplanets there are definitely shielding issues, etc.
@sundogplanets I keep trying to figure out whether there's been some breakthrough in space cooling that I don't know about (always possible, I don't know everything) or if tech investors are truly just so high on their own farts that they're throwing money at it on the assumption that "space is cold".
@sundogplanets Fear not, they have thought of this. The satellites will have 80m² radiators to dissipate the heat! https://spectrum.ieee.org/orbital-data-center-hype
@sundogplanets they simply buy them to increase demand, and send them to space to remove them from market to have a supply decrease, so prices go up
Will anyone ever check if they work in space?
@sundogplanets You heard it here first: this is another GPU smuggling racket.
@sundogplanets they have lofted NVIDIA GPUs into orbit to test, and at least for the short period of time they were up there the things worked ok. Given these things have a 3 year lifespan on earth in a data center, I expect they would die fairly quickly in orbit. (It’d only take one small CME impacting the planet to toast them all, I suspect)
@sundogplanets
As you know, Google launched a satellite with 4 TPUs (similar to GPUs) on Oct 1. Just 1kw power.
Apparently, it is doing well, writing Haiku poems 😜
The TPUs have held up against radiation in lab tests. The satellites probably have good shielding.
Maybe error corr/scrubbing in future for bit flips.
They are working on cooling using heat pipes and radiators.
But company admits space data centers cost 100x more than terrestrial.
https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/googles-project-suncatcher-runs-first-workload-on-orbital-tpu-but-company-admits-space-data-centers-cost-100x-more-than-terrestrial/
https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/models-and-research/google-research/google-project-suncatcher-facts/
@sundogplanets Wrap them in lead? The benefit includes that the air will taste sweet if a decommissioned one burns up in the atmosphere near you.
@sundogplanets
Also, every satellite and space probe uses a variety of techniques to deal with bit flips caused by radiation.
Am not familiar with techniques used with GPUs.
@sundogplanets
I actually know something about this! The answer is "yeah, for a while, but don't expect your money's worth."
You'd have all the problems you'd expect, but I think the silent killer here is latent failures that'd kill chips in the launch and the first few minutes of operation, plus elevated failure rate thereafter. Stuff tends to not work in space, but it tends to not work in strange and unexpected ways.
(I am slightly worried that the answer to this "lenders... can't fly to space to repossess them" problem would be "Well, the lenders just have to start their OWN space company!" because that seems to be everyone's answer to "SpaceX is kind of evil": "We should build our OWN megaconstellation")