I feel like I have a longer rant in me but . . .
One reason I think I roll my eyes particularly hard at all the tarot/magic shop/astrology/crystals ish, more than other things, is that at some level I'm disappointed at how fucking basic it all is.
Compare to other things people are into that I'm not, like horror movies. I can't watch them. I honestly have difficulty imagining ever wanting to. But I respect the genre when it's at its best, and when it's just pop, well, I love me some dumb fun too of other forms.
But I'm a grown up fantasy nerd. My childhood D&D class was always a mage or a druid or a cleric or something that could cast spells. So if you're selling magic shit to grownups, I kind of expect that I'd be at least a little tempted.
But come the fuck on. Italian playing cards that some weirdo cultists 200 years ago decided (wrongly) were secretly mystical in origin? I get that they have cool names. "Major arcana!" But . . . that's it?
One of the reasons we still have a Netflix subscription and probably will for a while is the availability of so many shows produced abroad, including shows that include a highly imaginative or fantastic element. The pulpy C-Dramas around neo-Taoist cultivation/immortals and such or Jordanian shows about djinn aren't any more believable than magic wands, but they're not rehashing the same tired old watered down Western Romantics shit.
And you can do better! Leigh Bardugo's Grishaverse is a great example of someone operating within the "scary witchery" historical framework but in new and interesting ways. (It was always a frustration of mine that however good they were at writing dialog and mystery structure, the anti-trans mogul's books barely complicated magic beyond "bippity boppity boo.")