Post by @davidgerard@circumstances.run

@davidgerard I started reading that. Based on my kids' ages and a memory I have of where I was reading it, I'm gonna guess that was 15 years ago. I forget how far I read, but I do remember going, in a single day, from thinking it was a neat concept to rolling my eyes here and there to actively arguing out loud with how annoyingly stupid the text was (yet so assured of its own genius). I mostly forgot about it (and rationalist wiki) until a few years ago.

Wraithe

@Wraithe@mastodon.social 12 hr. ago

@davidgerard Apparently Zoë Quinn has joined the party 😂:

“learning about the existence of Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality yesterday has sent me down the longest rabbit hole I have been on since having to figure out the weird interconnected web of alt right psychos that came for me. I'm STILL not done. if I develop a brain bleed, you know why”
https://bsky.app/profile/unburntwitch.com/post/3mtsc3dpqdk2i

View

ragman

@ragman@jawns.club yesterday

@davidgerard Man, I was a big fan of HPMOR when I was a teenager.

It really was quite a popular fanfic, and I think lots of people in the HP fandom of the time read it, without going into any of Yudkowsky's rationality brainrot on LessWrong.

I'm real glad I didn't get very sucked into it myself, and that I had a large amount of IRL people around me to keep me grounded.

For anybody who wants to learn more, the Behind The Bastards episode on the Ziz cult is well done.

DerivativeThoughts

@DerivativeThoughts@mastodon.social yesterday

@davidgerard People always think I'm exaggerating that none of the "AI Ethics" people have any formal philosophy, ethics, and in most cases CS background. They read Sci Fi and fanfic and get offended when you say stuff like "this was settled in a platonic dialogue, 3000 years ago". They actively distain anyone with any real knowledge.

lou.

@einsiedlerspiel@todon.nl yesterday

@DerivativeThoughts @davidgerard

Nick Bostrom et.al are proof that a formal Philosophy background really doesn't say much in that regard.

DerivativeThoughts

@DerivativeThoughts@mastodon.social yesterday

@einsiedlerspiel @davidgerard agreed but at least Bostrom has has done the reading and just come to myopic conclusions. Superintelligence is clearly a work of philosophy informed by the tradition in which he was educated.

The less wrong people will read nothing but their own farts, reinvent Pascal's wager and take it so seriously they start killing people to make their made up robot god happy.

David Gerard

@davidgerard@circumstances.run yesterday

@DerivativeThoughts @einsiedlerspiel Bostrom is also a serial idea thief, as documented by Emile Torres https://www.realtimetechpocalypse.com/p/41779538-5a1a-491d-b937-7e6d4ccd2683

Realtime Techpocalypse Newsletter

Stop doomscrolling and just read this! Click to read Realtime Techpocalypse Newsletter, by Émile P. Torres, a Substack publication with thousands of subscribers.

Möbius the Luddite

@moebius@oldbytes.space yesterday

@DerivativeThoughts @davidgerard this. Reading comprehension can be quite low too, I made a mistake introducing myself at a Humane Tech group full of "AI ethics" people and got cold reach out by some of those focusing on using AI to "research" how to govern AI... after I mentioned I think LLM is a big mistake and I'm in the anti LLM camp

Pteryx the Puzzle Secretary

@pteryx@dice.camp yesterday

@moebius @DerivativeThoughts @davidgerard
Also in "low reading comprehension" territory: apparently not being able to parse a straightforward hostile statement like "fuck off, bot-hugger".

Yes, that happened to me here in the Fediverse. I had to block the person because they refused to stop their unsolicited LLM-pushing and clearly thought I was just "not giving it a chance".

...dude, I was looking for a *rare* word. LLMs are better at common words.

Möbius the Luddite

@moebius@oldbytes.space yesterday

@pteryx @DerivativeThoughts @davidgerard the beating will continue until morale improves

1+ more replies

redsakana

@redsakana@infosec.exchange yesterday

@DerivativeThoughts Sounds like the same dynamic as the "chud vision of Roman history" that ACoUP had a post about recently: https://acoup.blog/2026/07/10/friday-friday-july-10-2026-on-the-chud-vision-of-roman-history/

To quote one of insights: "To put it in a metaphor, when it comes to a topic, a trained professional historian’s knowledge is often like a swimming pool that smoothly slopes from the shallow end to the deep end, while the autodidact enthusiast is sometimes more like a shallow puddle with really deep potholes. As a history educator, engaging with that autodidact enthusiast can be really rewarding, because they are often really excited to let you basically ‘widen’ their potholes, to overstretch the metaphor. But the chuds…it’s just a puddle. Not especially wide or deep."

@davidgerard

View

Michael Busch

@michael_w_busch@mastodon.online yesterday

@DerivativeThoughts @davidgerard

Members of the LessWrong apocalyptic AI cult also tend to get angry when you point out that they do their math wrong.

(e.g. the time I tried to explain to one of them that "Bayesian prior" is not the same thing as "make up a number".)

DerivativeThoughts

@DerivativeThoughts@mastodon.social yesterday

@michael_w_busch @davidgerard but making the numbers up is their favorite thing!

Michael Busch

@michael_w_busch@mastodon.online yesterday

@DerivativeThoughts @davidgerard

That particular LessWrong affiliate also seemed to like to do long series of chained probability calculations that all canceled out; conveniently reproducing the made up number he started with.

And that was when I ended the conversation.

2 more replies

Stefan Prandl

@redezem@aus.social yesterday

@davidgerard Gun to my head, having to choose between reading out HPMOR or My Immortal to my entire family…. I’m just saying they’re about to get some extremely weird goth fanfic. I mean HP fanfic tends to be bad but I just can’t stand how much HPMOR *thinks* it’s smart.

David Gerard

@davidgerard@circumstances.run yesterday

@redezem My Immortal has greater literary value

Maj - 🇨🇦

@maj@cosocial.ca yesterday

@davidgerard @redezem brand new sentence?

Jacob Alexander Tice

@daemonspudguy@app.wafrn.net yesterday

@maj@cosocial.ca @davidgerard@circumstances.run @redezem@aus.social

Fun fact: if you manage to make it through the entirety of My Immortal without dying you win absolutely nothing.

2+ more replies

David Gerard

@davidgerard@circumstances.run yesterday

@maj @redezem in times such as these

Engine of Creation 🏴‍☠️ 🦜

@goulien@mastodon.social 2 days ago

@davidgerard
No, thank you!
For Harry Potter Fan-fic, I‘ll just stay with „My Immortal“ and be happy with that. 😜

yomimono, still on earth

@yomimono@wandering.shop 2 days ago

@davidgerard the unlucky 10,000

George B

@gbargoud@masto.nyc 2 days ago

@davidgerard

I remember reading this forum post a long time ago which heavily influenced how I viewed Harry Potter (which were my favorite books when I was around the age of the characters in them)

https://forums.darklordpotter.net/threads/harry-potter-and-the-doctrine-of-the-calvinists.7970/

DLP

Harry Potter and the Doctrine of the Calvinists

http://ferretbrain.com/articles/article-161.html Harry Potter and the Doctrine of the Calvinists by Daniel Hemmens Dan Hemmens refuses to just...

Jernej Simončič �

@jernej__s@infosec.exchange 2 days ago

@davidgerard Loginwall bypasses:
https://skyview.social/?url=https://bsky.app/profile/clairewillett.bsky.social/post/3mtpvatugsc2z
https://skyview.social/?url=https://bsky.app/profile/panic.gay/post/3mtoakgupgk2x

A BlueSky thread by Butt teeth! Butt teeth! Butt teeth! on Skyview

Everyone on here is filled with a fresh batch or loathing for JK Rowling, so it seems like a good time to bring up that a shockingly large number of leaders within the AI world know each other because they were all part of a niche fandom that centered around a pretentious Harry Potter fanfic.

View

Rycochet

@Rycochet@furs.social 2 days ago

@davidgerard I can't wait to discover that the next generation of techfash grifters formed their views based on Peter Thiel's secret My Little Pony fanfiction about how selfishness is the real magic.

Tor Iver Wilhelmsen

@toriver@mas.to 2 days ago

@Rycochet @davidgerard «Friendship is Exploitable»

The Doctor

@drwho@masto.hackers.town yesterday

@toriver @Rycochet @davidgerard In that regard, MLP is a little too far in the past and Bronies too well established as a social group to really be subverted (c.f. Military Bronies).

I don't know what infection vector would be next.

Rycochet

@Rycochet@furs.social yesterday

@drwho @toriver @davidgerard Uh... You know that thanks to 4chan adopting it, the brony fanbase has a pretty huge nazi problem, right? It's already halfway there.

1+ more replies

David Gerard

@davidgerard@circumstances.run yesterday

@drwho @toriver @Rycochet MLP:Friendship Is Optimal, the fic worse than HPMOR, which used the Singularity as an excuse for enthusiastic description of finally getting to fuck one of the ponies

The Grouchybeast

@Grouchybeast@mastodon.social 2 days ago

@davidgerard The wildest thing about HMoR is that Yudkowsky isn't the first person who wrote a giant Harry Potter fanfic in order to found a cult. He isn't even the first person to write a giant HP fanfic in order to found a cult that eventually led to murder. That's just what happens in HP fandom, I guess.

Major Denis Bloodnok

@denisbloodnok@mendeddrum.org yesterday

@Grouchybeast @davidgerard OK, I'll bite - who's the first one?

David Gerard

@davidgerard@circumstances.run yesterday

@denisbloodnok @Grouchybeast

Thanfiction

the Snapewives were not murderous I think

Arda Xi :flag_nonbinary:

@ardaxi@hsnl.social 2 days ago

@Grouchybeast @davidgerard That can easily happen in any kind of community. It's just that HP got big at exactly the right time in the early internet for it to get that big.

David Gerard

@davidgerard@circumstances.run 2 days ago

@ardaxi @Grouchybeast Yudkowsky also picked HP for HPMOR specifically because it was a large fandom to recruit from

Laventeot

@Laventeot@wien.rocks 2 days ago

@Grouchybeast @davidgerard Should I try googling to learn more about the other HP murder cult(s) because they are grimly funny or should I stay blissfully innocent because they are just grimly sad?

(for example I find the zizians hilarious)