What Maintaining SwiftTerm Taught Me About AI Contributions:
@btel some do, yes; they should also ban contributors that drive cars or do air travel.
@Migueldeicaza @btel Banning contributors who drive cars is not the same thing as asking contributors not to drive their car directly into your living room to deliver patches.
Furthermore, in many places it is not possible to avoid driving cars if one wants to participate in society. The same cannot be said about using GenAI to write software.
Putting it charitably, this is a strained comparison to make.
@Migueldeicaza @btel Are you trying to imply that if they don't ban contributors who drive cars or do air travel, then they are also not allowed to ban ai contriubutors?
Because that sounds like a pretty bad policy. Imagine shops that are not allowed to prevent theft, because they don't also prevent adultery.
It's not all or nothing, you are allowed to make the world a little bit better as you can.
@Migueldeicaza @btel Are you implying that the machine-that-does-the-thinking-for-you is as essential as traveling to work or to see loved ones?
@Migueldeicaza @btel No. This is a bad take and you should feel bad.
@Migueldeicaza oooh this is โJohn Gruber saying X is ok if you watch HBOโ argument reskinned
@piyuv I am not familiar with that construct.
@Migueldeicaza@mastodon.social @btel@mastodon.social i've got an ethical question for you that I would love to hear the answer to; would you ban contributions made by actual slaves?
@CenTdemeern1 @btel happy to engage in a good-faith discussion, but I don't entertain loaded hypotheticals designed to extract a particular answer.
@Migueldeicaza@mastodon.social @btel@mastodon.social sure; one of the (many) reasons why generative AI usage is often banned in projects is because the way these models were trained was through the stealing of work by various artists and developers. Where I was trying to go with this question was that, through this logic, I consider using generative AI models stealing of the source material, which I consider unethical. What are your views on this?
@CenTdemeern1 @btel Excellent question, but not an easy one, because on one end of the spectrum there is the idea that *everything* should be free and there should be no property rights (that was RMS's original idea, but could not be realized, so the GPL/FSF were setup as a stop gap to eliminate those - details are fuzzy, but that is the gist of it).
@CenTdemeern1 @btel Intellectual property laws were setup as a mechanism to promote a particular way of sharing and to give people limited monopolies (details differ, but those are copyrights, patents, trade secrets, trademarks).
As a society, we get to choose what is in the best interest of society. Reasonable people will disagree on the multiple poles of this question (everything free, everything is locked up, everything in between plus naturalists etc)
@Migueldeicaza@mastodon.social @btel@mastodon.social While "everything should be free" is a nice ideal to have, is this not a violation of projects with incompatible licenses?
@Migueldeicaza@mastodon.social @btel@mastodon.social I don't think the robin hood mentality holds up in court last I checked
@Migueldeicaza this is mostly similar experience as what I've had. Re: the "provenance" thing, I have a feeling projects that have hard "no AI" provenance guards will end up falling behind in being able to keep up with things as they are much easier to replace nowadays, and there's probably going to be new programming paradigms replacing a lot of what we do anyway in the coming years (witness "Rewrite everything in Rust" as an early one).
@Migueldeicaza It's the endless debate about the necessity of the good guy with an LLM to counter the effects of the bad guys with an LLM. In the end everyone should be accountable yes, but you can't blame those who don't want to play that game.
@bladecoder They might not be, but it matters in terms of relevance, of expectations, of which projects survive and which do not, which ones serve their users and which ones failed their users. People resisted bug trackers, resisted security disclosures, resisted safe languages, and so on - there are plenty of valid reasons that people have for them.
They should at least do so from informed opinions and not two year old hearsay.
@Migueldeicaza i think many projects refuse AI patches on ethical rather than engineering basis. For example codeberg, or see some discussions in rust community. These are definitely valid concerns and I personally can very well relate to them.