I have a new laptop to install and I'm doubting between #Guix #NixOS and #Debian. I tried Guix a few months in 2025 but had many issues with lacking packages, unavailability of build infrastructure and lack of support for the chip architecture and legacy boot. I still like the philosophy behind Guix. NixOS seems more pragmatic and has a larger user base to get unstuck. But nothing can beat the vast packaging ecosystem and community of Debian.
@marcus Indeed, over 2 times as much. I didn't know that. But specific packages for fonts and conversion scripts for docbook aren't available in Nix/Guix.
@nicorikken @marcus it so easy to submit a patches, adding your favourite software to Guix ;)
@sharlatan @marcus I know, as I already followed that process back then. Especially easy now it is on Codeberg.
@nicorikken Twenty years with Debian and still in my heart, but loving NixOS now for reproducibility. For sure it is worth a try!
@asardone I too like the reproducibility. Unfortunately Debian never invested in this, although there is some system for system configuration.
@nicorikken In case you are interested, in Guix you can use Nix as a secondary package manager, if you need those additional packages:
"Nix service
The (gnu services nix) module provides the following service."
https://guix.gnu.org/manual/1.5.0/en/html_node/Miscellaneous-Services.html#:~:text=Nix%20service,the%20following%20service.
@shepherd Thanks, I knew that and I might have tried that previously. How good does this work in practice?
@nicorikken when I started with Guix I had it installed, at some point I've realized I don't need it. If anything I would just use Flatpak but nowadays I don't use anything that is not packaged in Guix. If I need something, making a package is easy enough (unless it's one of those more complicated software stacks).
I would say, don't be fooled by the numbers. Guix is one of the distributions with the biggest amount of packages.
Ow! Pick Guix! And blog (or post) about the installation.
@gijs Yeah I should blog more often.
Yep. And we should use the verb should less.
@nicorikken
The amount of narrow-sighted BS and hate that has been projected at #Debian lately is utterly insane.
But luckily, with the exception of the #HatersGonnaHate people, this will pass.
Debian still is, and will remain, a fortress and advocate of reliability.
Disclaimer: this is my personal opinion, other than being an avid Debian user I have no ties to the project.
@nicorikken
The amount of narrow-sighted BS and hate that has been projected at #Debian lately is utterly insane.
But luckily, with the exception of the #HatersGonnaHate people, this will pass.
Debian still is, and will remain, a fortress and advocate of reliability.
Disclaimer: this is my personal opinion, other than being an avid Debian user I have no ties to the project.
@nicorikken Guix has 32k + packages which is the fives place
The First is NixOs -120k
The third is Debian - about 60k
Works perfectly on Framework laptops and even on MacBooks
Already a few hours in and still no Guix on my laptop. Quite a struggle for various reasons.
@nicorikken Do also not underestimate the ecosystem of Arch. But when it comes to reproducabillity, it is either Guix or NixOS, where my preference is with the latter. And the rollback mechanism can be a lifesaver sometimes.
@ronnylam Arch seems too dynamic for my taste. And I too like reproducibility, declarativeness and roll-back. Having experience in Clojure, I'm very much convinced about the power of using a Lisp as a configuration language as Guix does. It makes it easier to extend the configuration language as it is left to the users and doesn't require changes by the project.
Another day, another attempt. This time I got the USB ath9k wifi dongle to connect to the wifi, so I now have an SSH session. So I think from this point on I'm good to install. 🤞 As I want to use BTRFS and will have to to use Nonguix kernel, I'll have to do a more bespoke installation.
With plenty of trial and error I managed to get the disk partitioning done, add a config.scm. It seems to boot, but locks up on the TTY. No blinking cursor and I can't switch to another TTY either. So there is probably something wrong with my config.scm.
What is a recommended #Guix installation with #Nonguix GNOME and Btrfs? I'm looking in the Guix manual for inspiration, but that one uses MATE because Rust wasn't available at the time and GNOME couldn't be built. That seems to be a solved issue now. https://guix.gnu.org/manual/devel/en/html_node/Using-the-Configuration-System.html
Changed the strategy again: now did a default install from Guix 1.5.0 and will rework the config later. Of course not the disk partitioning, but the nonguix kernel. I now installed Plasma, as I want to give that a try as well, coming from GNOME.
Turns out KDE Plasma isn't fully functional yet, as I had read already somewhere. All windows open in the top left corner and can't be moved. I'll try again with GNOME.
Managed to get a default install with GNOME working. Updated channels and config to Nonguix kernel. Had to resolve a DNS issue, but now it works. I'm now continuing with configuring the system. I'm glad to see packages available that I had to install via Flatpak previously.
@nicorikken quite an adventure Nico. I am trying to get GNU Trisquel Linux to run with Lomiri.
@os_sci Nice, that seems achievable as Trisquel is derived from Ubuntu, but there are probably quite some edge case.
@nicorikken Trisquel gnu Linux is one of the 5 FSF endorsed distros
@nicorikken according to https://repology.org/ nixpkgs has significantly more software than Debian.
Repology