Discussion
Loading...

Discussion

  • About
  • Code of conduct
  • Privacy
  • Users
  • Instances
  • About Bonfire
Neville Park
@nev@status.nevillepark.ca  ·  activity timestamp last month

So in this latest entry, Lucy starts getting blood transfusions—first from Arthur, then from Seward and Van Helsing as well.

Dracula was published in 1897; the ABO blood groups were discovered a mere 4 years later, in 1901.

What's the smallest gap you know of between a plot point appearing in a novel and a scientific discovery that renders it implausible?

In Adrian Tchaikovsky's Children of Time (published June 2015), which famously features UpliftedPortia jumping spiders, a minor plot point turns on their inability to hear. In October 2016, researchers discovered that jumping spiders can hear (news article), and since then hearing has been discovered in many other families of spiders.

Can anyone beat this?

____
All the transfusions are successful. The riskiness of blood transfusions, well known by then, is never mentioned. However, it's portrayed as a last-resort emergency measure where the risk of Lucy dying is far greater if she doesn't get a transfusion. This is another example of the novel stretching the bounds of known science/technology for artistic licence (the phonograph, which Seward uses for often long audio recordings, was less than a decade old and the cylinders could only record a few minutes' worth).

#DraculaDaily #ReDracula

  • Copy link
  • Flag this post
  • Block
Neville Park
@nev@status.nevillepark.ca replied  ·  activity timestamp last month

So in this latest entry, Lucy starts getting blood transfusions—first from Arthur, then from Seward and Van Helsing as well.

Dracula was published in 1897; the ABO blood groups were discovered a mere 4 years later, in 1901.

What's the smallest gap you know of between a plot point appearing in a novel and a scientific discovery that renders it implausible?

In Adrian Tchaikovsky's Children of Time (published June 2015), which famously features UpliftedPortia jumping spiders, a minor plot point turns on their inability to hear. In October 2016, researchers discovered that jumping spiders can hear (news article), and since then hearing has been discovered in many other families of spiders.

Can anyone beat this?

____
All the transfusions are successful. The riskiness of blood transfusions, well known by then, is never mentioned. However, it's portrayed as a last-resort emergency measure where the risk of Lucy dying is far greater if she doesn't get a transfusion. This is another example of the novel stretching the bounds of known science/technology for artistic licence (the phonograph, which Seward uses for often long audio recordings, was less than a decade old and the cylinders could only record a few minutes' worth).

#DraculaDaily #ReDracula

  • Copy link
  • Flag this comment
  • Block
Canageek
@Canageek@wandering.shop replied  ·  activity timestamp last month
@nev Yes, the version of Dracula that I read was an annotated one that talked about that, I wonder if anyone has sat down and done the math to work out the odds of them all being compatible blood groups?

I mean, I guess Lucy might have just been incredibly lucky and being AB positive and able to receive transfusions from almost anyone

  • Copy link
  • Flag this comment
  • Block
Sophie Jane
@ghost_bird@weirder.earth replied  ·  activity timestamp last month
@nev I think Larry Niven’s “The Coldest Place” was written just before and published just after Mercury was discovered not to be locked with one face to the Sun?
  • Copy link
  • Flag this comment
  • Block
Tak!
@Tak@gush.taks.garden replied  ·  activity timestamp last month
@nev In Jurassic Park (the book and the movie), Michael Crichton used the then-current hypothesis that tyrannosaurs had difficulty seeing things that weren't moving as a plot mechanism for protagonists to survive a T-Rex attack. This was discredited shortly after publication, and in the sequel, The Lost World, he's forced to reveal this and backsplain the dinosaur's behavior. (I'm not sure about the precise timeline.)
  • Copy link
  • Flag this comment
  • Block
Neville Park
@nev@status.nevillepark.ca replied  ·  activity timestamp last month

P. S.

Nature in one of her beneficent moods has ordained that even death has some antidote to its own terrors. Here, in a case where any shock may prove fatal, matters are so ordered that, from some cause or other, the things not personal⁠—even the terrible change in her daughter to whom she is so attached⁠—do not seem to reach her. It is something like the way Dame Nature gathers round a foreign body an envelope of some insensitive tissue which can protect from evil that which it would otherwise harm by contact.

Happy #GallWeek2025!

#DraculaDaily #ReDracula #GallWeek

  • Copy link
  • Flag this comment
  • Block
Log in

bonfire.cafe

A space for Bonfire maintainers and contributors to communicate

bonfire.cafe: About · Code of conduct · Privacy · Users · Instances
Bonfire social · 1.0.0-rc.3.13 no JS en
Automatic federation enabled
  • Explore
  • About
  • Members
  • Code of Conduct
Home
Login