This is the script of my national radio report yesterday on why separating the #Chrome Browser from #Google could be terrible for the vast numbers of Chrome users. As usual, there may have been minor wording variations as I presented this report live on air.
- - -
Well, the short answer is that it could potentially be a privacy and security disaster for literally billions of people around this planet.
The longer answer is pretty interesting. Indeed, one of the AI firms just offered 34.5 billion dollars (about twice what that company is theoretically worth) for Google's Chrome browser, and then almost immediately another AI firm offered a full 35 billion -- what's 500 million dollars among friends, right?
Of course, there's no obvious indication that Google has any interest in selling off Chrome at this time. Another factor is that there's speculation that the judge in an antitrust case that Google lost might order that Google divest itself of Chrome as part of a penalty, though that case is very likely to be appealed and go through considerably more litigation so we don't really know where that case will end up.
But the question you gotta ask yourself is WHY these firms would be willing to pay so much for Chrome. Yes, Chrome has about three and a half billion users who consider it to be their primary browser, and around a two-thirds global market share among the various browsers that users can choose from. And you're still talking about paying about $10 per user to get up to a $35 billion dollar offer. But the thing is, Chrome is effectively open source. These firms could essentially get the browser sources for free. The Google Chrome browser is based on the Chromium open source project, and that's the origin not only for the Chrome browser but also various other browsers. In fact, Microsoft's Windows Edge browser, that they're constantly trying to manipulate Windows users into switching to from other browsers, is itself based on the Chromium project.
So again, why are these AI firms willing to pay such an enormous sum for Chrome? And the answer is, they probably don't really care about Chrome per se, they care about those three and half billion users who use Chrome and could be dragged with Chrome over into these other firms' "AI First" philosophies, perhaps along with their browser histories and all the other data associated with routine Web use. So it's not the browser they lust after, it's the people who use the browser.
Now, as we've noted frequently, Google itself is going "full speed ahead" into AI whether users want it not -- and mostly it seems they don't want it. But that said, Google still has an excellent history of protecting and securing user data and privacy, related to their Chrome browser's use and other associated applications. This includes many routine Google and other services and for example the Chromebooks that are so popular in education and industry.
The thought of any of that data being handed over to some external entity or entities outside Google is of great concern to many observers in the security and privacy fields. What will happen if those 3.5 billion Chrome users are sucked into those other firms' AI fever dreams that again many -- polls say by FAR most -- users don't want to have anything to do with at all!
Yes, many people are critical of Google. But there's an old saying that the devil you know is better than the devil you don't know. And yes, I myself have been quite critical of various of Google's policy decisions, especially related to their Large Language Model generative AI push of late. But I've had, and still have, a great deal of respect and trust in terms of how the regular employees inside Google -- the Googlers many of whom I've known -- work to protect our data and our related privacy.
The upshot of all this is that billions of people conduct their Internet usage through the Chrome browser, and it's difficult to see how handing that browser -- and those users -- over to another firm doesn't stand a high probability of creating new privacy and security risks for those users who already have enough Internet problems to worry about -- so definitely stay tuned on this one! - - -
L
Firefox Addon
Chromium Addon